Pennsylvania Fieldwork Questions the Myth Behind the State's Data Center Boom
A team of anthropologists has completed two years of fieldwork in Pennsylvania on data center investment and finds a state split between a story of industrial revival and residents who do not trust it. The work, presented through photographs and a full report for Data & Society, also questions how anthropologists themselves do fieldwork.
- Anthropologists completed two years of fieldwork in Pennsylvania on data center investment and expansion.
- Some lawmakers and investors frame Pennsylvania as an "AI-ready" hub, citing its energy and natural resources.
- Residents, including those in Homer City, are skeptical, and the team documents growing opposition to data centers.
- The team used collaborative ethnography, challenging the myth of the lone anthropologist.
- A full report has been prepared for Data & Society.
A new chapter in an old industrial story
According to the Data & Society team, the push for data centers in Pennsylvania rests on a mythic narrative shared by companies and media outlets. That narrative presents data centers as the latest step in a long line of industrial development in the state.
The researchers describe data centers as facilities where data is processed or stored, where computer power is redistributed, and where "the cloud [also known as the internet] touches the ground." In their account, such a facility signals a centralization of information processing and distribution, especially because it houses the cloud and computing technologies that depend on its infrastructure.
The fieldwork took place as the United States marks the 250th anniversary of its independence. The authors argue that members of the executive, legislative and judicial branches are rewriting and weaponizing history, and they frame the data center story as part of a wider contest over American myths.
An "AI-ready" state and its skeptics
The researchers write that some lawmakers and private investors see Pennsylvania as a national hub for data center and AI infrastructure. They say this fits federal initiatives such as the Trump administration's AI Action Plan, which encourages state legislation to accelerate AI infrastructure and energy development.
The case for the state rests on its resources. According to the team, Pennsylvania is the second-largest natural gas and nuclear producer in the US, third in coal production, and has a large water supply. Sites mentioned in the piece include a location in Archbald, proposed for a future AWS data center, and a construction site outside Pittsburgh.
Residents see it differently in places. The authors say Pennsylvanians know boom-and-bust cycles from the state's industrial history, and that in areas such as Homer City, people are not buying the promises of the data center industry. They also report growing opposition to big tech and data centers on the ground, and pervasive distrust in government among residents.
The team asks whether AI investment is a return to blue-collar work and prosperity, a promise they say is sold by politicians and hoped for by communities that bore the brunt of rapid deindustrialization.
Rethinking how fieldwork is done
The project also turns the lens on anthropology. The researchers worked as a team: they observed together, co-wrote field notes, and are co-authoring a final report. They say this collaborative ethnography challenges the long-dominant myth of the lone anthropologist.
Fieldwork, they note, is often described as a "rite of passage" tied to a masculine figure "heroically roughing it in a faraway 'field' site in which he must test his own physical limits in a challenging environment." By working beyond traditional methods, the team says it parts ways with the "default fieldworker," who is historically situated, classed, gendered and racialized.
In their words, the approach questions ethnographic authority and acknowledges that anthropologists rarely work alone. The accompanying images, they say, reflect this reckoning as well as the complexity of a landscape and people shaped by decades of resource and labor extraction.
What it means
The piece offers no figures on investment, jobs or energy use. Its contribution is qualitative: a record of how a state pitched as ready for AI infrastructure looks from the ground, where promises of renewed prosperity meet memories of deindustrialization. For communities, companies and policymakers weighing data center projects, the researchers' message is that local trust is not guaranteed and that the story told about these facilities is contested. The full report for Data & Society contains the team's detailed findings.
Data & Society: Pennsylvania, Data Centers, and Challenging Myths of America and Anthropology


