CDT Warns AI Could Create ‘Synthetic Suspicion’ for Police Stops
The Center for Democracy and Technology is warning that AI systems used in policing could generate the justification for police actions instead of relying on evidence of wrongdoing. In an op-ed published November 18, 2026, CDT describes this risk as “synthetic suspicion.”
- CDT warns of AI-generated “synthetic suspicion” in policing.
- The US Border Patrol program scans automated license plate reader data.
- Vehicles can be flagged as “suspicious” based on driving patterns.
- CDT cites reported stops in California, Michigan, Texas, and Wisconsin.
- The organization says policymakers should act before the practice becomes routine.
When AI becomes the basis for suspicion
CDT argues that a free and democratic society depends on police restraint grounded in evidence. Its concern is that artificial intelligence could increasingly replace evidence, investigative techniques, and human review in police activities.
“Synthetic suspicion” describes a situation in which an AI system creates the justification for police action. CDT says policymakers should address the threat before this approach becomes a norm of law enforcement.
License plate data used to flag vehicles
The op-ed points to a predictive intelligence program at the US Border Patrol as an example. According to CDT, investigative journalists Byron Tau and Garance Burke reported last year that the program uses AI to scan the agency’s large collection of driving data from automated license plate readers.
The system then designates vehicles as “suspicious” based on driving patterns and flags them to be pulled over. The account presented by CDT raises questions about how a pattern identified by software becomes the basis for an encounter with police.
Reports describe similar stops
CDT also cites an account published last month by Jay Stanley of the American Civil Liberties Union. The account describes a September 2025 incident involving a woman on a multi-state road trip who was pulled over by an officer who identified themselves as being with the FBI. The officer said her driving pattern had been flagged as “suspicious.”
Stanley’s piece also lists other instances in which Border Patrol and police conducted car stops based on AI scans of driving patterns in California, Michigan, Texas, and Wisconsin.
Why the warning matters
For people subjected to these stops, CDT’s argument centers on how suspicion is formed and reviewed before police action takes place. A system that labels a driving pattern as suspicious can influence an officer’s decision, while the underlying basis for that label may come from an automated analysis rather than conventional investigative work.
CDT is calling for policymakers to respond before AI-generated justifications become routine. The organization’s warning places human review and evidence at the center of the debate over how artificial intelligence should be used in law enforcement.
Center for Democracy & Technology: Op-ed: ‘Synthetic Suspicion’ and the Perils of AI-Prompted Police Actions


