CDT Says COLLUDE Act Could Encourage Censorship Without Stopping Jawboning
The Center for Democracy and Technology is urging the Senate Commerce Committee to reject the COLLUDE Act, arguing that the bill could discourage useful government communications with social media and generative AI services. CDT also says the proposal would not stop unconstitutional government pressure on companies to censor speech.
- The Senate Commerce Committee will mark up the COLLUDE Act this week.
- The bill would change when Section 230 protects editorial decisions after government communications.
- CDT says the proposal could deter action on election and public health information.
- The organization argues the bill would not stop unconstitutional government jawboning.
- CDT supports Senators Cruz and Wyden’s JAWBONE Act.
Bill would change Section 230 protections
The committee is scheduled to mark up the “Curtailing Online Limitations that Lead Unconstitutionally to Democracy’s Erosion” Act, known as the COLLUDE Act, this week, according to CDT. The organization says the bill would amend Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act in two significant ways.
First, it would remove Section 230’s liability protection for “legitimate political speech” that an information intermediary removes or limits “as a result” of communication from a government entity, or from a non-government entity acting on behalf of one. CDT says the bill does not define “legitimate political speech.”
Second, providers and users relying on Section 230 would have to prove that they were not the information content provider for allegedly illegal information. CDT says this would turn Section 230 into an affirmative defense and increase the litigation costs faced by online intermediaries.
CDT warns against cutting off government information
CDT argues that the bill could expose companies to liability when they act on information supplied by government officials. Examples cited by the organization include election officials sharing information intended to reduce mistakes about polling places, and public health agencies providing updates about outbreaks and mitigation efforts.
According to CDT, the risk of losing Section 230 protection could deter companies from acting on reliable government information during fast-moving situations involving elections, public health, and disinformation campaigns. The organization also says companies should retain the ability, within their own editorial discretion, to reduce the reach of unreliable or false speech regardless of how they learned about it.
CDT says the bill could encourage proactive censorship of user speech that companies fear could lead to litigation. It identifies contested subjects including reproductive health, LGBTQ issues, religion, race, firearms, criticism of powerful political figures, and ongoing international conflicts.
Why CDT says the bill would not stop jawboning
CDT distinguishes between unconstitutional jawboning and ordinary, non-coercive communications. It says the government cannot coerce private entities to censor constitutionally protected speech because that pressure violates the First Amendment. The organization supports Senators Cruz and Wyden’s JAWBONE Act, which it describes as an effort to expose unconstitutional government pressure and create a way to restrict it.
In CDT’s view, the COLLUDE Act takes a broader approach by targeting editorial actions that follow any government communication, including non-coercive communications. The organization argues that removing Section 230 protection would not create liability for those editorial decisions and therefore would not address jawboning. It says responsibility and liability for unconstitutional pressure should instead be placed on the government.
CDT says changes to Section 230 require careful consideration of the interests of regular internet users. It is calling on the Senate Commerce Committee to reject the COLLUDE Act and pursue a more deliberative approach.
Center for Democracy & Technology: The COLLUDE Act Will Incentivize Censorship and It Won’t Stop Jawboning
